Liverpool officially confirmed the player’s return from his loan spell, raising fresh questions about what led to the move not working out.

Liverpool have officially confirmed that Lewis Koumas has returned from his loan spell at Birmingham City, a move that naturally prompts questions about why the arrangement failed to truly take off.

The statement on Liverpoolfc.com was brief and to the point, noting that the 20-year-old made 25 appearances across all competitions and scored once during his time at St Andrew’s.

On the surface, availability was not an issue. But when viewed through the lens of player development, the loan raises concerns. A temporary move is meant to offer consistent minutes, rhythm, and a defined role — all elements that were largely missing in Koumas’ case.

Why Koumas’ Birmingham loan stalled
The core issue is straightforward: he did not play often enough.

According to SofaScore, Koumas featured in 23 matches but started only seven of them, accumulating just 771 minutes. That equates to sporadic substitute appearances rather than the regular 70–90 minute outings that help young attackers sharpen their decision-making and confidence.

This lack of continuity explains why the loan ended without real momentum in either direction.

It is particularly notable given that Koumas has already shown he can cope with the physical and mental demands of the Championship, having enjoyed a more productive spell at Stoke. In comparison, his time at Birmingham feels like a sideways step rather than genuine progress.

Koumas himself hinted at the situation earlier this month, acknowledging the difference in game time compared to last season and revealing that discussions had taken place with Liverpool.

The numbers tell the story
A look at his 2025/26 league statistics underlines the issue. Limited starts led to limited impact.

With just one goal, three big chances missed, and low shot volume, the data points to a player who was never given a sustained run to find form — but also one who did not do enough in brief opportunities to demand a regular place.

From Liverpool’s perspective, the next step is uncertain. Arne Slot has shown little reliance on youth options this season, making an immediate pathway into the first team appear unlikely.

Koumas now needs a reset — another move that offers guaranteed starts and trust — to turn this loan return into a positive turning point. His ability has never been in doubt. He remains a Wales international, has already scored on his senior Liverpool debut, and comes from a strong footballing background as the son of former pro Jason Koumas.

But progress at this stage is built on minutes, not credentials.

Ultimately, while Koumas stayed fit and featured regularly in name, the lack of starts, modest output, and limited attacking influence meant the loan failed to deliver what it was meant to provide.